Wednesday, May 19, 2021
1960
Monday, June 4, 2018
Ringlessness
Monday, July 30, 2012
When We Were Young and Wild(er)
Friday, March 23, 2012
Which Best Place Is The Best?
Electric Square, Menominee, MI (JML photo)
Dear George,
When we were young, my father always claimed that Menominee and the U.P. were the best places to live. Our house was out in the country, and my parents loved nature. The scenery was beautiful, the air was clear, sunsets beautiful, the forest and the river were right outside our door, and we spent much of our leisure time swimming, boating, and camping. My mom gardened, my dad painted wildflowers, our dogs ran free. The town itself was right on Green Bay, the epitome of Michigan’s Water Wonderland. People in our small town were friendly, honest, helpful, and non- pretentious. When my dad would run across a news report that the population of the U.P. was declining, he’d respond that people were foolish and the more people that left, the better it would be for the rest of us. We may not have been as totally convinced as my dad, but we all agreed that Menominee was a special place.

Downtown Yellow Springs, OH
At eighteen I left home for Antioch College in Yellow Springs, a little college town of 3500 in southwestern Ohio. At first Yellow Springs seemed pretty rinky-dink. It had a two-block business district, one gas station, one drugstore, one grocery store, one hardware store, and one traffic light. It didn’t take long, however, to discover how idyllic the Yellow Springs village was. Antioch had a strong “beatnik” culture which gave the whole community an avante garde atmosphere. The town was home to numerous artists and writers. The Little Art Theater had a reputation as the best foreign film cinema in the Midwest, and Com’s Tavern and the Highway 68 Drive-in soon became late-night havens for my friends and myself. By the time I was approaching graduation, Yellow Springs had become home and the prospect of leaving was traumatic. Menominee had been good, but I’d concluded that Yellow Springs was the best.

Liberty St., Ann Arbor, MI
Katja and I married and moved to Ann Arbor for graduate school. I was heartbroken and wary. I was skeptical about going to a Big Ten school, and I was sure that, as dedicated Antiochians, we would never feel at home in a collegiate place like Ann Arbor. All of those worries vanished within weeks. The University of Michigan was an awesome institution, and the city of Ann Arbor was remarkable. The streets surrounding campus were full of bookstores, cafes, movie theaters, and elegant shops like Artisans and John Leidy’s. Katja and I became U of M football fans, and we decided that life in Ann Arbor was wonderful. Menominee and Yellow Springs had been good, but Ann Arbor was the ultimate.

Cincinnati skyline
In 1966 I took a faculty position in Cincinnati, and we were distraught about leaving Ann Arbor, our first married home. Cincinnati’s campus area business district couldn’t hold a candle to Ann Arbor’s, and the local rightwing media turned us off. All of our angst turned out to be temporary, however. Compared to Ann Arbor, which now seemed like a small college town, Cincinnati was truly a big city -- far more complex, diverse, and interesting. We discovered Cincinnati’s panoply of fine restaurants, including world-class establishments like the Maisonette and Pigall’s. Cincinnati is one of the premiere cultural centers of the Midwest because of its symphony, opera, ballet, chamber music, and theater. It has fine art museums; one of the nation’s best zoos; professional and college sports; seven hills, interesting architecture, and desirable neighborhoods. After a while we came to realize that living in a big metropolis was much more exciting than anywhere we’d lived before. Menominee, Yellow Springs, and Ann Arbor had been excellent in their own ways, but Cincinnati topped them all.
When I thought about all this recently, I got confused. It dawned on me that, wherever we happened to be currently living, I’d thought that that place was the greatest. How can one ever find the truth? Luckily I ran across a website called “City-Data.com” that offers an amazing amount of information about all the towns and cities in the U.S. I used it to look up facts about Menominee, Yellow Springs, Ann Arbor, and Cincinnati. I compared the four places by geography, climate, population characteristics, economy, and various amenities. Which place, I wondered, would objectively turn out the best? A scientific approach would surely give the answer.
The detailed results from City-Data.com are in the appendix below. I wasn’t surprised to find that each of these desirable places ranked number one on various dimensions. In fact, there was a three-way tie between Yellow Springs, Ann Arbor, and Cincinnati. Each was ranked number one on three different dimensions. Here’s where these three places get their top rankings,
respectively:
Yellow Springs: #1 on per capita income, % of residents married, and estimated % of lesbian and gay households.
Ann Arbor: #1 on educational level of residents, lowest unemployment, international diversity (% foreign-born).
Cincinnati: #1 on county population growth, restaurants per capita, and low adult obesity.
Well, what about Menominee, you ask? As my dad would have predicted many years ago, it pretty much sweeps the awards. It winds up #1 on 16 of the 25 dimensions I looked at: Low population density, low commuting time, low poverty rate, low cost of living. Greatest water area, highest air quality, coolest summer temperatures, lowest rainfall, fewest natural disasters. More Swedes, more Lutherans, more religious affiliation, more bars per capita, more pastie shops, more deer, fewest violent crimes.

Green Bay shoreline and Menominee Marina
Admittedly, not all of these Menominee attributes translate directly into quality of life. Like Garrison Keillor on Prairie Home Companion, we have a certain affinity for Scandinavians, Lutherans, and pasties, so we tossed those into the mix. Deer population might seem low in relevance, but when you’re from the U.P. it’s a major priority. Menominee’s number one ranking on both religion and bars may be puzzling at first, but when you’re familiar with Menominee culture it makes perfect sense. It appears that my dad was right after all. Statistics don’t lie -- Menominee is practically the best place there can be. It just goes to show – those early impressions often turn out to be the most accurate.
Love,
Dave
P.S. If you want to see why Seattle, Santa Cruz, New Orleans, Philadelphia, East Lansing, Princeton, Rochester, New York City, Charlotte, or your home town are great places, just go to www.city-data.com. You’ll be pleasantly
surprised.
APPENDIX (Rank order of four cities and their scores on 25 dimensions):
Low population density (per sq. mi.): Menom (1582), YSprgs (1725), AnnArb (4178), Cincy (4271)
County pop. change (2000-10): Cincy (+0.5%), AnnAr (-1.0%), Menom (-10.3%), YSprgs (-12.9%)
% Water area (vs. land): Menom (5%), AnnArb (.03%), Cincy (.003%), YSprgs (0.0%)
Travel time to work: Menom (9 mins), AnnArb (19 mins), Cincy (20 mins), YSprgs (21 min)
Per capita income: YSprgs ($32K), AnnArb ($27K), Cincy ($24K), Menom ($21K)
Low poverty rate: Menom (15%): YSprgs (18%); AnnArb (21%): Cincy (26%)
Unemployment rate: AnnArb (7.5%), Cincy (8.6%), YSprgs (8.9%)(, Menom (9.0%)
Cost of living (US Ave = 100): Menom (77), Cincy (90), Yellow Springs (92), AnnArb (92)
% Married: YSprgs (53%), Menom (51%), Cincy (34%), AnnArb (34%)
% BA degrees or higher: AnnArb (69%), YSprgs (59%), Cincy (27%), Menom (13%)
Diversity (% foreign-born): AnnArb (17%), YSprgs (3.8%), Cincy (3.8%), Menom (0.8%)
Swedish ancestry: Menom (10%), AnnArb (>2%), Yellow Springs (>2%), Cincy (>2%)
Lutherans: Menom (22%), YSprgs (5.3%), AnnArb (5.2%), Cincy (>2%)
Lesbian & gay couples (est.): YSprgs (2.4%), AnnArb (0.9%), Cincy (0.6%), Menom (0.2%)
Affiliated w/religious congregation: Menom (69%), Cincy (49%), YSprgs (34%), AnnArb (33%)
Violent crimes (per 10K residents): Menom (11.7), YSprgs (13.9), AnnArb (18.6), Cincy (44.9)
Adult obesity rate: Cincy (26.6%), AnnArb (27%), YSprgs (28.6%), Menom (28.8%)
Temperature (highest monthly ave.): Menom (81), AnnArb (83), YSprgs (84), Cincy (87)
Rainfall (highest monthly ave.): Menom (3.6”), AnnArb (3.7”), YSprgs (4.4”) Cincy (5.1”)
Air Quality Index (low = better): Menom (9), AnnArb (32),YSprgs (39), Cincy (42)
Natural disasters (e.g., floods): Menom (4), AnnArb (8), YSprgs (9), Cincy (12)
Restaurants (per 10K residents): Cincy (7.5), AnnArb (7.2), Menom (7.0), YSprgs (5.6)
Bars (per 1000 residents): Menom (1.1), YSprgs (0.6), AnnArb (0.3), Cincy (0.2)
Pastie Shops: Menominee (3), Ann Arbor (0), Yellow Springs (0), Cincinnati (0)
County deer population: Menominee (46K), Ann Arbor (26K), Cincinnati (8K), YSprgs (6K)
Main Sources: www.city-data.com; www.yellow-pages.us; Google Images
G-mail Comments
-Mary B (3-25): You got me going on this one, because I'd said my entire adult life I'd never live in Florida; then family circumstances brought me to Gainesville in 2000. My sister-in-law reassured me with that year's #1 ranking of Gainesville. Over the years that hasn't always been true, but in 2007 we were again ranked #1 by Sander and Sperling on economy, cost of living, climate, education, health, crime, transportation, leisure, and arts and culture; more specifically, "the presence of 'college town amenities' such as athletics and museums." Looking for more recent data, I discovered we were ranked on March 17, 2011 among the Ten Happiest Cities! I'm glad my personal experience is matched by statistics. I've grown to love all those things about Gainesville. Yet... I still miss Cincinnati. Thanks for the memories.
-Jennifer M (3-25): the website you refer to is crazy! what a lot of information!
Wednesday, March 30, 2011
Gender Politics

Geraldine Ferraro (1935-2011)
Dear George,
We were saddened last week when we learned that Geraldine Ferraro had died at age 75. For many of my students she was probably a footnote in history, but for our generation she was a living, breathing vital figure in late twentieth century American politics. She ran, of course, as the vice-presidential nominee with Walter Mondale in the 1984 election against incumbents Ronald Reagan and George H. W. Bush. Ferraro’s V.P. nomination, the first for a woman in U.S. history, represented the culmination of two decades of work by the Women’s Liberation Movement, and Katja and I saw her as an outstanding politician: bright, articulate, assertive, knowledgeable.
We were in our forties in 1984 and had seen monumental changes in American society during our lifetimes. Menominee in the 1940’s and 50’s, when I was growing up, was a small town in a conservative, isolated region. While my parents and their friends were undoubtedly enlightened compared to the community at large, traditional gender stereotypes and discrimination were the rule of the day. My paternal grandmother had been state chairperson of the Wisconsin Republican Party, and my dad and mom were staunch conservatives. In our North Woods world, men were “manly men”, women their helpmates, and there were no questions about who was head of the household. Few women in my parents’ friendship group worked outside the home; families were larger than nowadays; and the sexes had a traditional division of labor. I do believe that the adult women and men that I knew as a kid respected and delighted in one another, but males and masculine values clearly enjoyed higher esteem by all concerned.
While I don’t really know for sure, I’d bet that I was the only high school student from the U.P. to ever attend Antioch College. I discovered from the first day of freshman orientation that I was naïve and backwards politically and culturally compared to my more cosmopolitan classmates, many of whom came from left-wing families in East coast metro areas. I recall listening to some of my new classmates discussing the pros and cons of socialism. I had heard vaguely of socialism, but I had it confused with “social diseases”, and I couldn’t imagine what some of my peers found so appealing about syphilis and gonorrhea.
Racial issues were beginning to come to the forefront of societal debate in the late 1950’s, and some of the first civil rights picketing in the nation was done at Yellow Springs’ segregated barber shop. My hallmates and I patronized the black barber shop at the edge of the town’s business district as our mild form of protest. Katja was a member of the local NAACP and more sophisticated about political matters than I. When we talked about gender roles, she argued vehemently for women having lifelong careers, while I tended to dwell on the supposed rewards of motherhood. Katja’s opinions, of course, eventually held sway.
We married in 1960 and went off to graduate school at Michigan. Pharmaceutical companies had just completed their trial tests in Puerto Rico of birth control pills, a revolutionary new breakthrough, and Ann Arbor had been selected as the first site in the U.S. for testing on the mainland. Katja was in the initial group of enlistees, and I used to accompany her to her monthly exams at a second floor office suite on a darkened block of Liberty St. between campus and downtown. She joined Planned Parenthood and then became a charter member of N.O.W. when it was launched in 1966.
Katja L. (1972)
By the time we were living in Cincinnati in the early 1970’s, the Women’s Liberation Movement had gained substantial momentum. Katja was a T.A. in the French department at the University, and she formed a women’s consciousness-raising group composed of friends and colleagues. Soon afterwards she began to notice that whenever she called her friend Ellin both of them would hear a strange clicking sound on the telephone when they first connected. Katja called Bell Telephone to complain about wiretapping, but Bell claimed they would never do that without informing their customers. It was the midst of the Nixon years, and we both felt that wiretapping of a feminist group leader was a distinct possibility. Our phone conversations became less spontaneous.
Katja’s women’s group rotated among the members’ homes, and, over time, I got to know each of the participants, at least superficially. After a few months I got the distinct sense that people were giving me unpleasant looks when I passed in the hallway. I asked Katja what their consciousness-raising discussions were about, and she said they were about individuals’ personal lives. I wondered whether this might include their husbands, but I didn’t pursue the question. The only thing I know for sure is that every group member got divorced in the next two to three years except Katja. She claimed it was because we had the most solid marriage, but I think it was mostly luck.
I wish Geraldine Ferraro or her surrogates were still around today. Sarah Palin and Michele Bachmann seem to be sharing the limelight as women politicians, and, despite Palin giving public credit to Ferraro for paving the way, they are fraudulent imitations. Gender politics, of course, have come a long way since 1950. But they seem to still have a long way to go.
Love,
Dave
G-Mail Comments
Jennifer M (3-30): This is great. I didn't know about Katja's and your roles in the "rights" movements. Thinking back on the goals of the women's movement, Sarah Palin and Michelle Bachman are put in new light.
Wednesday, September 1, 2010
Newlyweds

Young Marrieds at River House [July, 1961]
Dear George,
Katja and I were married fifty years ago this past Saturday. It’s hard to imagine. We were 23 at the time and viewed ourselves as grownups. Now I think we were closer to being babies. I can’t imagine how we undertook this major life step, much less how we survived it.
We got married in Yellow Springs on Aug. 28, 1960, had a one night honeymoon in Dayton, and moved a week later to Ann Arbor where we were beginning grad school. We arrived in Ann Arbor with an ill-founded snobbism from our undergraduate experience. Antioch was like a cloistered island in southern Ohio, surrounded by conservative communities (e.g., Cincinnati) whose media constantly attacked the campus as a leftwing stronghold. Antiochians consequently developed a strong in-group identification and maintained a sense of superiority to the external world. I initially viewed Michigan as a big and probably mediocre public university, though I soon discovered that it was an astonishing place and that my view of the academic world was seriously distorted.
We rented a second-floor apartment on Brookwood St. near campus in a house owned by 80-year-old Mrs. Quackenbush. Mrs. Q had been renting to Michigan students for decades, and she was a fair and business-like landlady, if a bit old school. Our apartment was tiny, but it was our first home and we loved it. I had retrieved a tree stump with all its roots from the Menominee River earlier in the summer, and we bought a round piece of glass and made it into a coffee table. We made another table out of a wooden whiskey crate that we’d bought for a dollar at the local state liquor store. Katja bought a big rocking chair with lion’s head arms from the Salvation Army for $8, and we still have it in our living room, though sheepdog puppies did some chewing on its legs.
Grad school was serious business, and I applied myself day and night. Katja delayed her plans to begin M.A. studies in French, and, to help support us, she took a job as a clerk at Faber’s Fabrics which had stores in downtown Ann Arbor and at Arborland. Katja became immersed in her new job, took weekly sewing lessons, and began turning out homemade shirts for me and napkins and tablecloths for our household. Between my graduate stipend of $1,450 for the year, a small monthly allowance from my parents, and Katja’s weekly salary, we were able to eat and pay the rent. We went out for lunch once a month at the Pretzel Bell, a famous Ann Arbor college hangout, and enjoyed prime roast beef sandwiches and gravy.
One day I came home, and there was a fuzzy little ball of black fluff that turned out to be a German Shepherd puppy named Heather. Katja thought we needed a third party to be a real family. We loved the little dog, and our non-work lives soon centered around her. Then a tragedy occurred. We’d left her in the care of a friend, who tied her up in the back yard, and Heather scaled a wire fence, tumbled over, and strangled to death. We were in a state of grief for a long time. It was our first occasion for dealing with a traumatic event as a married couple. We’re still sad when we think about it.
Antioch had prohibited intercollegiate athletics , and we thought it weird to be at a Big Ten school. Students, however, received free tickets to the football games, so we went to the first game of the season at Michigan Stadium, along with 100,000 others. Katja, despite not knowing much about football, loved the pageantry of it all. The game was exciting, and the halftime Michigan Marching Band was even better. After that first outing we only missed one or two home games during our six years in Ann Arbor. We even went now and then to watch the marching band practices which were held in a field a couple of blocks from our apartment. One enduring byproduct was that we came to hate Ohio State with a passion.
Managing money was scary to me, so I was happy when Katja volunteered to take care of our finances. We opened our first checking account at the Ann Arbor bank. Looking at it in hindsight, Katja was remarkably systematic and frugal. We, of course, didn’t have much money to spare. Consequently she only wrote checks for the amount of each single purchase. $4.89 here, $12.50 there, and so on. We’d been in Ann Arbor for about six months when we stopped at the bank to cash a check, and the clerk at the window said that the branch manager wanted to talk to us. Puzzled, we went into his office. He explained that the bank’s board of directors had spent their entire February meeting discussing policy issues regarding our account. It turned out that we were averaging over thirty cashed checks a month, mostly for amounts under ten dollars, and the bank’s costs in processing our account were excessive. I can’t believe they were that excessive, but it apparently was a very serious matter for the bank. The manager explained how we could cash a check for more than an item’s purchase price, and then he gave us an ultimatum: either stop writing all these small checks or find another bank. Katja changed her check-writing practices. An impartial observer might say that that marked the end of frugality in our married life.
My parents came down to visit in the spring at the time of the Ann Arbor Art Fair. We all went together. Katja saw a painting that she fell in love with. I remember it as being very large and very colorful. The price tag was $700. Katja wanted it with all her being. In fact, she asked my parents if they would lend us the money. She said she couldn’t go on living without it, and I think she meant it. My mother, a fledgling mother-in-law at that time, was horrified. She told me privately that Katja’s unchecked desire for luxury didn’t bode well. I was a little nervous myself, but I told her how remarkably frugal Katja was. My mother wasn’t convinced. Little did I know.
The academic year came to an end. Katja was committed to traveling, and she chose the Seattle World’s Fair in Seattle as our first destination. She had saved a few dollars each week from her Faber’s Fabric paycheck, and so we had $200 (plus my father’s Standard Oil gasoline credit card) to cover a six-week trip to the West Coast. We set out from Menominee in July. I’ll have to tell you more about that another time, but I’ll just say for now that this was a momentous time in our lives.
Love,
Dave
G-Mail Comments
-Linda C (9-3): The bank story is just great. And your dog story is soooo sad I will call u soon. Great updates on the twins. What is too late to call?
-Vicki L (9-2): Dear David, Whenever I hear of your days in Ann Arbor, I wish we'd been there together for a longer period of time (it must only have been one year). I'll always think of Katja at Faber's. I knew nothing about going to football games - just think, you could've introduced me and my whole life might've turned out differently (eg. I may've become a cheerleader instead of a hippie). By the way, I refuse to believe the man in the picture is actually you - it's clearly Katja but as far as I'm concerned she's standing with a young Ralph Buscher. Love, Sis
-Donna D (9-1): david, this is great! can you make the picture bigger? it is awfully hard to see. but it could just be my eyes,,,,:) donna
-David to Donna (9-2): Hi Donna: I agree the pic would be better larger, but I was unable to do so. David
Wednesday, June 16, 2010
Dr. Swanson's Exciting Seminar (or: How I Lost My Wedding Ring)

Dear George,
My favorite professor in grad school was Guy Swanson. He was the head of the Soc Department at Michigan and taught a core seminar in our social psychology program. Swanson was extremely well-read, articulate to the point of being flowery, and readily able to span the gamut from macro-societal phenomena to the intricacies of everyday social interaction. I wrote down everything he said in class and emulated his style of thinking as much as I could.
Curiously my most memorable experiences in Dr. Swanson’s seminar didn’t have to do with academic content, but with other classroom happenings. One of these occurred in late November 1963. Swanson had just started discussing distinctions between Georg Simmel and Charles Horton Cooley when one of my classmates, Rich J., came into the room and announced that President Kennedy had been assassinated in Dallas. The class was stunned. Dr. Swanson commented on what a terrible tragedy this was, paused for a few seconds, then analyzed the remarkable capacity of social institutions to maintain equilibrium in the face of catastrophe, and finally returned to his comparison of Simmel and Cooley. The students just sat there in silence. Finally Dave B., one of the more mature members of my cohort, politely expressed to Dr. Swanson that he didn’t think that class members were able to go on. Reluctantly, Swanson conceded. I ran to a pay phone and called Katja who was working at her part-time sales job at Faber’s Fabrics. Katja had already gotten the news and she was crying uncontrollably over the phone. We didn’t recover for a long time.
A few weeks later Dr. Swanson had moved on to Talcott Parsons and the critique of structural functionalism. The room was stuffy, and because I was seated at the end of the table, he asked me to open the window. I did so, but after a while it got too chilly, and he asked me to close it. The window didn’t come down easily, so I stood up on the windowsill and applied more force. As the window started coming down I jumped off the sill. My wedding ring, however, got caught on the window latch, and, as my body dropped to the floor, my hand stayed caught on the latch. The ring stripped away a big chunk of flesh from my finger, and only then did my hand come free. Blood started pouring out all over my clothes and the floor. Swanson sent a class member to the department office to notify his secretary to call for medical help. The secretary did so and came back to the classroom with a vial of smelling salts which they kept in the department office for just such occasions. I was in a state of shock. The main thing running through my mind was that, since I would no longer be able to type with my left hand, my scholarly career was all but over. Soon the ambulance arrived, and the paramedics carted me off to the emergency room at the U. of M. Medical Center.
The medics stopped my finger from bleeding. Then the task was to get my wedding ring off so they could patch up the injury. Because there was a lot of stripped off flesh in front of the ring, they couldn’t pull the ring off my finger. One of the residents started using a small metal file to cut through the ring. Thirty minutes later he hadn’t even made a dent. After some brainstorming, the staff transported me to dental surgery. There a doctor cut through my ring in no time at all with a diamond drill, bent the ring open, and pulled it off. I was taken in a wheelchair back to the emergency room, where they sewed me up. Thankfully the tear, though it nearly circled my finger, was a flesh wound, and none of the muscles had been severed. The doctor told me that they dealt with this sort of injury nearly every day, nearly always with men who’d been wearing their wedding rings while doing manual labor. I was their first case from a classroom seminar.
I took my severed wedding ring home, and Katja said she would buy me a new one. I just shook my head. I explained to Katja what the doctor said and that I wasn’t going to be wearing a wedding ring or any other sort of ring ever again. She was disappointed about that, but I think she eventually came to terms with it. I still have the scar which encircles my ring finger. Just looking at it is unpleasant. Swanson, though, remains my favorite professor.
Love,
Dave
Saturday, March 13, 2010
Banana Reveries

Dear George,
I see in the paper that the number of people in their late 50’s who smoke marijuana has gone up 350% since 2002. That’s because those aging baby boomers are returning to habits they developed in their youth. Katja and I, a decade older, basically missed out on the whole counterculture drug revolution. When we graduated from Antioch College in 1960, I don’t think a single student on campus had ever tried marijuana. There simply was no system of distribution on college campuses at that pristine time. A few years later, Antioch had become the drug capital of southwestern Ohio, but we had already moved on to the serious grind of graduate school in Ann Arbor. We kept reading in the local newspaper about marijuana arrests of Michigan undergrads, but we didn’t know anybody in town who had tried pot, and, while curious about these new mind-altering substances, we lacked the connections to do anything about it. Then one day I saw a story in the Ann Arbor News which reported that one could get high by smoking banana peels. That was interesting. Maybe this was our chance to experiment with drugs. The reporter even gave instructions. I showed it to Katja, but the notion had no appeal to her at all. I pointed out that smoking bananas was perfectly legal, as well as relatively cheap, and I proposed that we try it. Katja raised her eyebrows and made a funny face, but she did drive over with me to the supermarket on Packard St. As I paid for my purchase of 17 bananas, I asked the cashier if they’d been selling a lot. She said they actually had, though she didn’t know why. I smiled knowingly. Then we stopped at the Blue Front magazine store at the corner of Packard and State where I purchased some Zig Zag cigarette papers. I felt self-conscious doing this since there was only one obvious reason for such a purchase. I looked around carefully for NARCs before I asked the clerk for the item.
Back home, I checked the recipe again. It said you only use the peel of the banana and throw away the fruit itself. As virtually penniless grad students, three bunches of bananas did cost something, so I ate the seventeen bananas for my lunch. Seventeen is quite a few – you should try it some time. Then I scraped the stringy fleshy part off the inside of the banana peel, threw it away, put the cleaned out peels on a pizza tray in the oven, and cooked them on low heat for two hours. Finally I crumbled up the dried out peels into tiny pieces and rolled a bunch of cigarettes. Despite her reluctance, I got Katja to share the first one with me. She’d been smoking Black Russian cigarettes with her friend Murielle, but she’d never really learned how to inhale, and the banana peel cigarette made her choke. She exclaimed that it tasted awful. I smoked the rest of the cigarettes, drawing the smoke deep into my lungs. They did taste pretty bad. I was already feeling sick from eating seventeen bananas, and smoking the peels only made me sicker. I didn’t know exactly how to tell if I were high, but I was pretty sure that this was not it. After an hour of unsuccessful effort, I went to bed and stayed there for the rest of the day
Later, disgusted with the experiment and our waste of money, I re-read the newspaper blurb. I was shocked to find out that I’d made a big mistake in preparing the banana peels. The article said to scrape the innards off the peels, throw the peels away, and bake the innards. Instead I’d thrown the innards away and baked the peels. I’d done the whole thing backwards! That’s why I didn’t get high, I thought to myself. I considered starting over again, but Katja was discouraging, and I didn’t want to spend the money for more bananas. I finally concluded we’d had our shot, and destiny had decided that we weren’t ready for a radical life style change. That was the end of our venture into hallucinogenic drugs.
Now it’s 45 years later. Out of curiosity, I did a Google search on “smoking banana peels,” not knowing whether there would be any historical trace of this brief fad or not. Much to my surprise, I got 106,000 hits. I didn’t read all of them because the first ten explained that smoking banana peels was a hoax perpetrated on naïve and gullible youth in the 1960’s and 70’s. If kids had had any experience of getting high, the Internet accounts said, it was probably due to indigestion from eating a lot of bananas. That made me feel better. I was relieved to learn that it didn’t matter whether I had smoked the dried out banana peels or their innards. I guess I’d had an authentic banana high experience after all.
Love,
Dave
G-Mail Comments:
-Amy R (3-15): This is so great.
-Linda C (3-15): dave, I love this story, however ruth and susan and I did not miss that age and would/could have a lot of explaining to do, which unfortunately I told all under a light anesthetic to my colonoscopy doctor. (and later the colonoscopy doc had a lawsuit against him which I dismissed immediately).
-JML (3-13): great story dad. I seem to remember some elements of this story from my youth but not the whole deal. a follow up story that i'd like to see might include some of your tennis playing adventures with george. again, I remember some elements of that but not the whole deal. great blog today. thanks, j**